FusebLAWg: LGBT rights and the SCC decision on hate speech
A step forward or a step back?
By: Frances Truong
On February 27th, the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) upheld the hate speech provision in Saskatchewan鈥檚 Human Rights Code (SHRC) while striking out parts of the provision as overly broad. The judges effectively removed a prohibition on publication that 鈥渞idicules, belittles or otherwise affronts the dignity,鈥 reducing the prohibition on publication solely on grounds of exposing 鈥渉atred.鈥 They reasoned that the wording of the legislation did not capture the same level of 鈥渆xtreme鈥 feelings towards the targeted group as the word 鈥渉atred.鈥 In doing so the legislation placed too broad of a limitation on freedom of expression and could not be justified as a constitutional limitation in a free and democratic society.
While I applaud the Court鈥檚 decision in upholding the hate speech provision, I find the decision to strikeout the more expansive prohibition to be problematic, particularly for gays and lesbians in Canada.
Read full post
FusebLAWg covers a variety of topics and issues which fall broadly under the scope of legal studies. As a collaborative project between the students, faculty and staff of 杏吧原创 University鈥檚 Department of Law and Legal Studies, FusebLAWg aims to be a leading source of information on contemporary legal affairs and important discussions in Canadian legal scholarship.